
Truck Accident Lawyers | Bakersfield, CA
When a Truck Driver Runs Past the Hours Allowed, Families Need Answers
Colvin Accident Lawyers works with families across Kern County, Fresno, Visalia, Lancaster, Palmdale, Delano and Tehachapi after fatal truck crashes.
By Donald Norman Colvin · Published November 14, 2026
A family that loses someone in a truck crash often asks one hard question: did the driver break the hours rules?
If a commercial truck driver broke hours-of-service rules before a fatal crash, that violation may be part of a wrongful death claim. If you have lost a loved one in a crash, Colvin Accident Lawyers, based in Bakersfield, California, represents families in wrongful death cases.
Short Answer: Can an Hours-of-Service Violation Support a Fatal Truck Crash Claim?
Yes. Negligence, in plain terms, means failing to use the care a reasonable person would use.
Fatigue matters because a tired driver may react slowly, follow too closely, or drift out of a lane. A log that shows too many driving hours gives a family a concrete fact to work from. Those facts can help explain how the crash happened and who had a role in it.
The federal rules apply to property-carrying commercial motor vehicles, the trucks that haul freight. A violation does not prove every part of the claim by itself. The family still has to connect the violation to the crash and to the losses. How much a violation matters depends on the facts of the crash and the records that exist.

What the Federal Hours-of-Service Rules Require
The federal rules limit how long a commercial driver may drive and how long the driver may work before resting. Under 49 CFR § 395.3, a driver may not drive until taking 10 consecutive hours off duty. Driving is also barred after a 14-hour period that begins when the driver comes on duty after that rest.
Under 49 CFR § 395.3(a)(1), a driver must have 10 consecutive hours off duty before driving.
Longer limits apply too. Under 49 CFR § 395.3(b), a driver may not drive for any period after 60 hours on duty in any period of 7 consecutive days if the employing motor carrier does not operate commercial motor vehicles every day of the week, or after 70 hours on duty in any period of 8 consecutive days if it does. Which of those limits applies depends on whether the carrier runs trucks every day of the week. Under 49 C.F.R. § 395.3, any period of 7 consecutive days may end with the beginning of an off-duty period of 34 or more consecutive hours, and any period of 8 consecutive days may end with the beginning of an off-duty period of 34 or more consecutive hours.
A log that shows compliance is a claim about the driver’s time. It is not proof of rest.
Records That Show Whether a Violation Happened
The most useful records are ELD data, dispatch records, and receipts, because each can be checked against the driver’s log. An ELD automatically records date, time, location, engine hours, vehicle miles, driver or authenticated user identification, vehicle identification, and motor carrier identification data (49 CFR § 395.26). Those entries can show when the truck was moving and where it was.
Dispatch timing can show whether a driver was pushed to make a delivery on a tight schedule.
Fuel receipts can carry time and place details that can be compared with the log. Roadside inspection reports can show earlier hours problems or other compliance issues. Prior records matter because they can reveal a pattern rather than a single day.
Time limits matter here. A carrier must also keep a backup copy of ELD records for 6 months, on a device separate from the one storing the original data (49 CFR § 395.22). That short window is why early written requests to preserve records matter.
Hours-of-Service Records in a Wrongful Death Claim
Whether a wrongful death claim can be proven depends on the facts of each case. It mainly shows that a rule was broken. The family must still connect that break to the crash and to the losses.
California law makes a person responsible for injury caused by a want of ordinary care or skill in managing their property or person, except so far as the injured person brought the injury on themselves, willfully or by their own want of ordinary care (Civil Code § 1714). A violation can be one piece of proof of carelessness. It is not automatic liability in every case.
The link matters most. Evidence that a driver exceeded driving limits carries the most weight when it lines up with fatigue, slow reaction, or a lane departure shown by the crash evidence. Federal rules also bar driving when fatigue makes it unsafe (49 CFR § 392.3).
Who may bring the claim is also a question. Code of Civil Procedure § 377.60 lists who may assert a wrongful death claim. That includes a surviving spouse, a domestic partner, and children.
The family’s losses are documented separately from the violation. Damages reflect the decedent’s circumstances and what the survivors lost. The violation does not measure those losses by itself.
Common Defenses From Trucking Companies and How They Are Answered
A carrier may argue that its logs were accurate, that the driver was rested, or that the violation did not cause the crash. Each argument can be tested against the records.
- “The logs were accurate.” Compare the log with ELD data, receipts, and dispatch times. Federal rules bar any false report about duty status and any tampering with an ELD so that it does not accurately record and retain required data (49 CFR § 395.8).
- “The driver was rested.” Count the on-duty hours across the prior 7 or 8 days. Check the 10-hour rest before the shift. A 34-hour off-duty break can end a cycle, so the count must start from the right point.
- Under 49 CFR § 390.11, whenever a duty is prescribed for a driver in part 325 of subchapter A or in this subchapter, or a prohibition is imposed upon the driver, it is the duty of the motor carrier to require observance of such duty or prohibition, and if the motor carrier is a driver, the driver is likewise bound.
- “Something else caused the crash.” Reconstruction data, witness accounts, and the sequence of events test that claim against the timing of the driving hours.
Frequently Asked Questions About Hours-of-Service Violations and Fatal Truck Crash Claims
What are the potential legal consequences for a truck driver or company after a serious incident?
Civil claims can name both the driver and the trucking company. Federal rules make the carrier responsible for requiring drivers to follow the limits that apply to them.
Who is most at fault in a rear-end collision involving a truck?
Fault comes from the evidence, such as following distance, speed, braking, and any signs of fatigue. There is no single answer for every crash.
Can a trucking company be responsible when its driver broke the hours rules?
A claim can reach the carrier when its dispatch, scheduling, or record-keeping is part of the evidence.
Does a log violation automatically mean a claim will succeed?
No. A violation is one piece of evidence, and it must connect to the crash and the losses.

Talk With Colvin Accident Lawyers About Your Family’s Situation
A family may be asking whether a driver’s logs and a company’s dispatch records could matter to a wrongful death claim. That question often comes up after a loss, when the family is still grieving and has little time to sort through paperwork.
Hours-of-service evidence can be complex. A single log entry rarely tells the whole story. Records need to be requested, compared, and read against the facts of the crash.
Colvin Accident Lawyers is based in Bakersfield, California. Your first consultation is free, confidential, and comes with no obligation to continue. No one can predict the outcome of a case, and each case stands on its own.
If your family lost someone in a crash with a commercial truck, Colvin Accident Lawyers can talk through the driver’s logs and records with you. You can contact Colvin Accident Lawyers to begin that conversation.
Donald Norman Colvin is responsible for this page.
How Our Team Approaches a Fatal Truck Crash Claim
Reviewing the Driving Records
We look closely at logs, electronic data, dispatch and fuel records, and other documents that show when a driver was on duty and how long they had been driving.
Supporting Grieving Families
Our team keeps families informed in plain language and handles the details of the claim so loved ones can focus on what matters most to them.
Holding Responsible Parties Accountable
Claims arising from a fatal crash may involve the driver, the trucking company and others. We examine every possible source of responsibility.
A Free, Confidential First Consultation
Your first consultation is free, confidential and carries no obligation to continue. You can ask questions and decide what comes next.
Act Early to Protect the Evidence
Trucking records can be changed, overwritten or lost over time. If you lost someone in a truck crash, contact us as soon as you are able so the evidence can be reviewed while it is still available.
Types of Cases We Handle
Truck Accident Claims
Crashes involving commercial trucks, including collisions where driver fatigue or schedule pressure may be part of the story.
Wrongful Death
Support for families who have lost a loved one because of another person's negligence or misconduct.
Catastrophic Injury
Representation for people whose injuries will affect their work, daily life and future for years to come.
Bus and Passenger Vehicle Crashes
Claims arising from crashes involving buses and other passenger transportation.
Motorcycle and Bicycle Crashes
Help for riders and cyclists hurt by drivers who failed to see them or failed to share the road safely.
Pedestrian Accidents
Assistance for people struck while walking, including those injured in Kern County and the surrounding communities.