
Car Accident Lawyer · Bakersfield, Kern County
How Hard Is It to Win a Car Accident Lawsuit in California?
The answer depends on the evidence, the injuries, and how the insurance process unfolds. Here is what shapes each stage, and how Colvin Accident Lawyers approaches it with you.
By Donald Norman Colvin · Published November 15, 2026
If you were hurt in a car crash, or a family member was, you may be asking how hard it is to win a car accident lawsuit. How hard a claim is to pursue depends on your crash, your injuries and the evidence you can gather. Here is how the process works.
What “Winning” a Car Accident Lawsuit Can Mean
Winning usually means you receive payment for your losses, either through a settlement or a court judgment. Many claims start as a request to the at-fault driver’s insurer. A lawsuit is a case filed in court, and it usually comes later, when that request does not resolve. Some cases settle through negotiation. Others go to trial, where a judge or jury decides. Some end with no payment at all. The path and timing differ from case to case, so it helps to plan for more than one outcome.
If you were hurt in a crash, or you are worried about a family member's claim, our team is glad to talk through your situation with you. Talk it through with our team — the first consultation is free, confidential, and carries no obligation.
What a Plaintiff Must Prove
To win, the injured person, called the plaintiff, must prove negligence. Duty means drivers must use ordinary care. Civil Code § 1714 makes a person responsible for injuries caused by a want of ordinary care. Breach means the driver fell short of that care. Speeding is one example. Vehicle Code § 22350 bars driving faster than is reasonable or prudent for the conditions.
Causation links the breach to your injury. If a driver runs a red light and hits your car, the question becomes whether that act caused the harm you claim. Damages are the real losses you suffered. The insurer will test each part. It may argue you were not hurt in this crash or that something else caused your injuries. Expect each element to be questioned.
How California Divides Fault When Both Drivers Share Blame
If your losses total 100 points and a judge finds you 30% at fault, you recover 70 points.
When fault is disputed, the case turns on evidence. Each side offers its own version of the moments before impact. When more than one party is responsible, Civil Code § 1431.2 limits each defendant’s share of non-economic damages. Each one pays only its own percentage of fault for those losses. How fault gets divided depends on what happened in your crash.
The Evidence That Carries a Car Accident Claim
The strongest claims usually rest on evidence that shows how the crash happened and how it hurt you. Useful items include the police crash report, photos of the vehicles and scene, witness names and statements, traffic citations, and vehicle damage that matches the impact described. A traffic violation can help. Evidence Code § 669 lets a court presume a person failed to use due care when that person violated a statute, ordinance, or regulation, the violation caused injury, the death or injury resulted from an occurrence of the nature which the statute, ordinance, or regulation was designed to prevent, and the injured person was within the class the rule protects. The driver can rebut that presumption.
Prompt medical care and steady treatment records help connect your injuries to the crash. A long gap in treatment gives an insurer an argument. Act early to preserve evidence. Vehicle data, video and photos can disappear over time, and the other side may start building its defense quickly.
Damages: Economic and Non-Economic Losses
Damages are the money value of your losses. They fall into two groups. Economic damages are objectively verifiable monetary losses, such as medical bills, lost earnings and repair costs. Non-economic damages are subjective losses, such as pain, suffering, emotional distress and loss of companionship. Civil Code § 1431.2 defines both terms.
Each category needs proof. That means itemized bills, pay stubs or employer records, and medical notes that describe the injury and its limits. No single formula fits every claim. The value of a claim depends on the proof behind each loss, not on a rule of thumb.
Factors That Make a Car Accident Case Harder to Win
The hardest cases usually involve disputed fault, a weak link between the crash and the injury, or a missed deadline. Here are the main hurdles.
- Disputed fault. Conflicting statements and no independent witnesses leave the story open to argument.
- Medical gaps and other causes. Insurers may argue an older condition or missed treatment caused the harm.
- Impaired driving. Under Civil Code § 3333.4, an injured driver convicted under Vehicle Code § 23152 or 23153 cannot recover non-economic losses.
- Vehicle Code § 23123.5 bars holding and operating a handheld phone while driving, unless the phone is specifically designed and configured to allow voice-operated and hands-free operation and is used that way. A phone may also be operated by hand only if it is mounted on the windshield, dashboard, or center console in a permitted manner and the driver uses a single swipe or tap to activate or deactivate a feature. That can help show breach.
- Deadlines. Code of Civil Procedure § 335.1 California Code of Civil Procedure section 335.1 generally provides a two-year period for actions for injury or death caused by the wrongful act or neglect of another, but shorter deadlines and exceptions, such as delayed discovery or tolling, can apply to some claims, so contact our team promptly. Under Code of Civil Procedure § 335.1, the general period for an action for the death of an individual caused by the wrongful act or neglect of another is two years, but other deadlines and exceptions can apply, including shorter deadlines for claims against public entities.
- Medicare repayment. If the injured person is a Medicare beneficiary, CMS explains that conditional payments must be repaid from a settlement or judgment.
Results depend on the facts of each case, and results will differ if the facts differ.
Not sure what your next step is?
Talk it through with our team — the first consultation is free, confidential, and carries no obligation.
Common Questions About Car Accident Lawsuits
A case tends to look stronger when fault is clear, injuries are documented, treatment is steady, and other evidence backs up the account.
What is a settlement offer measured against?
An offer is measured against documented medical costs, lost income, the fault evidence, and how the injury affects daily life. California treats an insurer’s failure to promptly provide a reasonable explanation for a denial or compromise offer as an unfair claim practice when the insurer does so knowingly and with such frequency as to indicate a general business practice.
Does more medical treatment raise a settlement?
Treatment counts only when it is medically needed, documented, and tied to the crash. A procedure does not add value on its own.
Do I need a lawyer to bring a claim?
You can file an insurance claim yourself. A lawyer can investigate, gather evidence, negotiate, and file suit when needed.
Talking With Colvin Accident Lawyers About Your Situation
If you are weighing a crash you did not choose, the next decisions can feel urgent. You may be handling this for an injured parent, spouse or child. You may be deciding whether to speak with the other driver’s insurer, what records to keep, and whether the claim should move toward court.
La consulta inicial es gratuita, confidencial y sin compromiso de continuar. (The initial consultation is free, confidential, and carries no obligation to continue.)
If you want to talk through your crash, your records, and the timing in front of you, you can contact our team to start that conversation.
Colvin Accident Lawyers, Bakersfield, California — responsible for this site. Responsible lawyer: Donald Norman Colvin.
What Shapes a Car Accident Case
Medical records and bills
Treatment records, bills and prognosis notes show what the injury has cost so far and what it may cost going forward.
Lost income
Pay stubs, employer records and time missed from work help document how the crash affected your earnings.
Insurance communications
Adjusters often request recorded statements and quick signatures. What you say and sign early can affect the claim later.
Daily life after the crash
Pain, limits on everyday activities and emotional strain are part of the full picture of your injury.
Talk with a lawyer before you sign anything
Before you give a recorded statement to an insurer or sign a release, speak with a lawyer about what the document says and what it could affect.
How a Car Accident Lawsuit Usually Unfolds
Investigation
Gathering police reports, photos, witness information and vehicle data builds the factual record of how the crash happened.
Claim and negotiation
Your claim is presented to the at-fault party's insurer, supported by documentation of your injuries and losses.
Filing a lawsuit
If the claim cannot be resolved fairly, a lawsuit may be filed so the case can move forward in court.
Resolution
Many cases resolve through settlement, while others proceed to trial. Each path depends on the facts of the case.